But his 3-6, 6-2, 6-3, 6-4 second-round win over 99th-ranked Damir Dzumhur suggests it could be a struggle for the 20-time grand slam winner to get to an appetizing rematch with men’s favorite Novak Djokovic in the semifinals.
Usually racing out of the blocks and suffocating opponents, Federer has lost the first set in his opening two rounds at a major for the first time ever in his career.
On Monday in New York, it was Indian qualifier Sumit Nagal who grabbed the first set.
Is the 38-year-old still reeling from a gut-wrenching defeat to Djokovic in the Wimbledon final last month or was he simply feeling the effects Wednesday of competing under the roof on Arthur Ashe Stadium, where it is seemingly more difficult to breathe?
Last year outdoors on Ashe, Federer conceded the conditions got to him in a fourth-round reverse to John Millman. That evening, though, was much hotter.
Or is it nothing of concern, really, a rare yet minor blip?
Federer himself had no idea why he has started shakily, by his lofty standards.
“I don’t know,” he told reporters. “I have been in that position many times where you go through a little phase where you don’t start so well and everybody asks you right away, ‘What are you going to do?’ You’re like, ‘I don’t know.’ Just go back to the drawing board. Just do the same things again. You hope for a better outcome.
“I don’t think there is per se a secret to a good start other than warming up well, being well prepared mentally. Not underestimating your opponent. I did all of that. You know me, I will always do that.
“So when it happens like this back-to-back matches, it’s just a bit frustrating more than anything, especially when the level is that low and there is that many errors and the energy is not kind of there. But can only do better, which is a great thing moving forward.”
His coming matches indeed are sure to tell us more and the weather might have benefited Federer in one respect.
Advantage for Federer?
He will next face either pal Lucas Pouille or Britain’s Dan Evans, and the persistent rain meant their second-round match was pushed back to Thursday after Wednesday’s day session on non-covered courts was officially canceled shortly before 6 p.m. local time.
The winner thus won’t have any rest ahead of battling Federer on Friday.
“I think this roof is more important when it comes to semis and finals than a day like today, because they’re going to fall behind, matches are going to get canceled, and then other players have to back it up, back-to-back days,” said Federer. “So it’s going to be tough.
“Here I definitely profit from everything I guess I did in the game and my ranking to be put on center court on a day like this.”
Like their two previous contests — back to back in 2015 at the French Open and Wimbledon — Federer and Dzumhur put on a show thanks to dazzling variety and shotmaking.
The 5-foot-9-inch Bosnian — ranked as high as 23rd last year — raced to a 4-0 lead as Federer’s forehand went awry. Not only did he take the first set, but Dzumhur held a break point to start the second.
No wonder one of Federer’s twin daughters looked slightly nervous in the stands.
Federer, though, saved it and would save six of eight break points altogether.
At times the usually unflappable Federer let his frustration show, like when he missed a backhand overhead in the third set, a set where Dzumhur was visited by the trainer for an apparent abdominal issue.
But Federer ultimately collected his 87th victory at the US Open on Wednesday. If he reaches 92 next week, he would end the longest title drought for him at any major having last triumphed in the Big Apple in 2008.
Another legendary grand slam champion will have to wait until 2020, meanwhile, to end her own grand slam drought stretching to 2008.
Venus exits after coffee break
In other day session action, Venus Williams, a year older than Federer at 39, fell to No. 5 seed Elina Svitolina 6-4, 6-4 under the roof on Louis Armstrong Stadium despite an acrobatic volley to fend off one match point in a game lasting more than 15 minutes deep in the second. Svitolina — a Wimbledon semifinalist this summer — needed six match points overall to prevail.
Don’t ask Williams — who wanted a coffee on court for the second straight tournament — about retirement, though. She has already said she intends on playing in 2020, which is also an Olympic year.